Why Nobody Follows Your Processes: The Creativity vs. SOPs Difficulty

The Lifecycle of a Project Manager: From Assistant Project Manager to COO

Why Nobody Follows Your Processes: The Creativity vs. SOPs Difficulty

As someone deeply entrenched in the construction industry, it’s evident that contractors face a recurring challenge—balancing creativity with standardized procedures. During my years in the industry, I’ve observed countless attempts to streamline operations with Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs). While necessary, they often come at the cost of stifling employee creativity and initiative. Let’s unravel this complex issue and find a middle ground that nurtures both process adherence and innovation.

The Importance of SOPs

SOPs are the backbone of any growing organization. They provide clarity, consistency, and reliability, critical for an industry as demanding and unpredictable as construction. For contractors aiming to expand beyond their current geographic boundaries, SOPs ensure everyone operates from the same playbook. They serve as the blueprint for successful project execution, especially when new employees, ingrained with different methods, need to align with your firm’s ethos and operational style.

To learn more about how to develop an SOP, click here.

The Creativity Quotient in Construction

However, construction isn’t a paint-by-numbers job. It’s a dynamic field requiring creativity at every turn. To craft structures that are not only functional but also innovative, one must be a self-starter. This adaptability and creative problem-solving ability are the traits that distinguish mediocre projects from extraordinary ones. As an owner, your role is to provide a framework that guides without suffocating this creativity. 

The Pitfall of Overly Rigid SOPs

Unfortunately, many contractors overdo it with their SOPs, aiming to micromanage every aspect of daily operations. In doing so, they inadvertently stunt the creative drive of their employees, leading to disengagement and high turnover rates. Here lies the heart of the conundrum: How do you determine which processes are essential for uniformity and which areas require freedom for individual ingenuity?

Essential SOPs: Safety and Compliance

Certain aspects of construction necessitate stringent processes. Safety protocols are paramount. For example, in the event of an injury on-site, there must be a clear, universally understood procedure. This includes knowing which hospital to transport the injured to, the hierarchy of emergency contacts, and the specific paperwork that needs immediate completion. These aren’t just formalities; they are vital steps that ensure swift, effective action in urgent situations.

Beyond emergency response, regular safety routines play a critical role. Morning huddles and toolbox talks are SOPs that foster a culture of safety and preparedness. By making these entire organizational habits, you embed a non-negotiable standard of safety.

Streamlining Administrative Processes

Administration is another domain where SOPs shine. Tasks like compiling monthly pay requisitions, handling invoices, and orchestrating project start-ups benefit from detailed procedural guidelines. A well-structured SOP delineates each team member’s responsibilities and the sequence of actions to be followed, ensuring nothing falls through the cracks.

For instance, consider the monthly pay requisition process. Each step—from its compilation to its submission and approval—must be meticulously outlined. At what point does it go to the owner? When does it circle back to the accountant? Such clarity prevents bottlenecks and ensures a smooth workflow.

Project Kickoff: A Case Study in Essential SOPs

A project’s initiation phase, whether a multi-year endeavor or a shorter-term construction project, is crucial. During these early stages, the groundwork laid can make or break the project. Procedures for project kickoffs must be well-defined to ensure all necessary documentation and preliminary steps are completed on schedule.

When things kick into high gear—from the first shovel hitting the ground onward—these initial steps should facilitate continuous progress. Any oversight during this phase can lead to costly delays and inefficiencies later on. For smaller contractors handling shorter projects, compressing these startup routines into the first few weeks is vital to keep the momentum going.

Defining Estimation and Sales Processes

Estimation and sales are other critical areas that benefit from well-defined processes. Knowing precisely how to pursue potential projects, from initial contact to final negotiation, is essential. This includes a step-by-step guide to business development, follow-up calls, and proposal preparations. These processes should be honed and standardized to increase win rates and build a repeatable, scalable sales strategy.

The Balance of Process and Creativity in Operations

While the aforementioned areas thrive on robust SOPs, operational creativity should not be constrained. Each construction project is unique, presenting distinct challenges and opportunities. It’s impractical and detrimental to dictate rigid procedures for activities that benefit from on-the-fly problem-solving and innovation.

Take my own experience, for instance. I created a comprehensive binder 21 years ago, documenting every new operation I undertook. This detailed record included production rates, manpower, equipment used, pitfalls encountered, and troubleshooting tips. Having this reference has proven invaluable, yet it serves as a guide rather than a set of ironclad rules. It allows adaptation and adjustment based on each project’s specific needs.

Empowering Managers and Supervisors

For project managers, supervisors, and foremen, this flexibility is crucial. Their role often involves making quick decisions based on the immediate situation—something rigid SOPs can hinder. Promoting the habit of creating personalized operational guides, much like my binder, encourages them to draw on past experiences while remaining adaptable to the nuances of their current project.

Projects have individual personalities, characterized by unique variables such as location, environmental factors, stakeholder dynamics, and unexpected challenges. Recognizing and embracing this individuality fosters a culture of creativity and problem-solving. Employees feel trusted and empowered, which not only improves job satisfaction but also leads to more innovative and effective project solutions.

Cultivating a Culture of Process Adherence with Flexibility

The challenge is fostering a culture where SOPs are respected and followed for critical tasks while allowing flexibility in creative decision-making. Here are some strategies to achieve this balance:

1. Clearly Distinguish Between Essential and Flexible Processes:

  - Develop clear criteria to differentiate which processes are critical for consistency and compliance and which areas can benefit from individual initiative and creative solutions.

2. Create Comprehensive Training Programs:

  - Invest in training that emphasizes the importance of SOPs for safety and administrative tasks while highlighting the value of creative problem-solving in operational aspects.

3. Encourage Documentation of Experiences:

  - Motivate employees at all levels to maintain records of their experiences, challenges, and solutions. This not only creates a valuable knowledge repository but also fosters a culture of continuous learning and improvement.

4. Solicit Feedback and Promote Open Communication:

  - Regularly seek feedback from your team on the effectiveness of current SOPs and areas where they feel constrained. Encouraging open dialogue helps in refining processes and addressing concerns proactively.

5. Leverage Technology for Process Management:

  - Utilize project management and collaboration tools that allow flexibility while ensuring that critical tasks are tracked and completed as per the SOPs. This helps in maintaining a balance between adherence and adaptability.

6. Recognize and Reward Innovation:

  - Create recognition programs that celebrate innovative solutions and creative problem-solving. This reinforces the value placed on creativity within the framework of necessary processes.

Listening and Adapting: A Continuous Process

The construction industry is evolving, driven by technological advancements and changing client expectations. As contractors, our ability to stay ahead of the curve depends on our flexibility and adaptability. Implementing SOPs should never be a one-time task but a continuous process of learning, adapting, and refining as we gain new insights and face new challenges.

Inviting Diverse Perspectives

It’s pivotal to involve team members from various levels and departments in the process review and development. Their diverse perspectives can uncover pain points and opportunities for improvement that might otherwise go unnoticed. By doing so, you not only enhance the effectiveness of your processes but also foster a sense of inclusion and ownership among your employees.

Finding Your Unique Balance

Striking the right balance between process adherence and creativity is a nuanced art. While SOPs are indispensable for ensuring safety, compliance, and administrative efficiency, it’s equally vital to promote a culture where creativity and innovation thrive. As an industry, we must continually seek this equilibrium, recognizing the unique characteristics of each project and the invaluable contributions of our teams.

Embracing this dual focus will not only enhance project outcomes but also build a more engaged, motivated, and innovative workforce. So, the next time you draft or review a process, ask yourself—does this guide my team without restraining their creative potential? If the answer is yes, you're on the right path.

If you require help with getting your teams aligned with your processes, reach out to Jerry Aliberti directly at jerry@pro-accel.com  or schedule a call directly below.